Some Leftover Thoughts about "The Holdovers"
For the last eight years, I’ve had the pleasure of being a guest on The Freshman Fifteen, a podcast created by two dear friends and fine film aficionados, Jeremy Bear and Daniel Long, and a regular contributor to their Oscar specials. This year, I rolled into the gig a bit addled: I’m doing chemo to knock out colon cancer and the side effects include fatigue and fogginess that can make it hard to articulate coherent thoughts. So, I wrote a lot of notes for myself for the 2024 Oscar pod – and my notes for one of the Best Picture nominees, The Holdovers, grew into something you could call an essay. I decided to read every word of it – a mistake. Worried about making our epic Oscar episodes longer than they already are, I rushed through it, which didn’t help the cause of coherency. And it didn’t help the cause of brevity! Which is why we decided to cut that section and turn it into a bonus episode.
I was also encouraged to post this “essay” online. What follows, however, isn’t a transcript of my podcast pontificating. It’s a next-draft version of the remarks I wrote for the podcast. I felt it needed more context to work as a read. And I couldn’t resist the opportunity to tinker further with it – and make it even longer. More knowledgeable film minds than mine will likely quibble with how I summarize movie history and characterize the cultural conservation about the movies; I won’t fight them if they do. And the writing really runs out of gas at the end. Blame it on the chemo. And yet, I publish! For I have opinions, and they must be posted!
"History is not just a study of the past, it is an explanation of the present."
-- Paul Hunham (Paul Giamatti) in The Holdovers
The Holdovers, directed by Alexander Payne (Election; Sideways; The Descendants), is an ironic take on A Christmas Carol, set at the gloomy dawn of the seventies, with post-sixties malaise chilling the American soul and more bad weather to come. Our grinchy Scrooge is a boarding school professor, Paul Hunham (Paul Giamatti, great as always), who’s stingy with grades and gangrene with cynicism. He teaches ancient civilizations with dogmatic, punishing zeal -- big Roman Empire fanboy; "Meditations" by Marcus Aurelius is his Bible -- yet he doesn't like to reflect too much on his own life. Resentment and regret poisons him. His students suffer his toxic seep. Yet there's a sweetheart locked up inside this haunted sourpuss; an intervention of spirits is needed to guide him to a moment of clarity and opportunity for change. He gets them in the form of two other bluesy souls in need of Christmas grace and New Year’s renewal: Angus Tully (Dominic Sessa in a striking screen debut), a bright student struggling with abandonment and mental health issues, seemingly hellbent on self-destruction, and Mary Lamb (Da’Vine Joy Randolph, Oscar golden in her every moment), the school’s cook, spiraling into despair over the death of a son killed in Vietnam. They play prickly psychopomps to each other, prodding each other to lament and reckon, pushing each other to drop the baggage – or at least hold it better – that hinders them from moving into the future as freer, braver, more hopeful people.
I loved The Holdovers – the characters, the performances, the story, the humor, the rich recreation of a time and place, the depiction of what people can mean to each other when they dare to be vulnerable with each other and wrangle with each other with growing care and commitment.
But me being me, what I want to go on and on about is the thing that many movie nerds love talking about when they talk about The Holdovers: the meta of it all. The Holdovers isn’t just set at the start of the seventies. It’s made in a way to look, sound, and feel like a movie from the seventies. It belongs to a genre of post-seventies movies that are nostalgic for a moment in time known as New Hollywood, in which the film industry (the studio system and an outbreak of upstart independents) broke with established aesthetic modes and limiting content codes to engage a changing, restless audience hooked on TV, turned on by New Wave cinema, and/or wanting to see their counter-culture perspectives and concerns depicted on screen. Bonnie and Clyde, The Graduate, Midnight Cowboy, Easy Rider, Five Easy Pieces, Harold and Maude, The Godfather, so many more – it all seemed to augur a new golden age of cinema. (For more on that pivot, read Pictures at a Revolution by Mark Harris, which locates the shift in the tumultuous movie year of 1967, and for a survey of everything that followed, there’s Easy Riders, Raging Bulls by Peter Biskind.)
This period of filmmaking made a massive impact on the generation of filmmakers, film critics, and serious cineastes who came of age during the seventies. Indeed, for most of my moviegoing life, a recurring refrain in the discourse has been a pining for the good old days of New Hollywood risk-taking and artistry and grieving for its complicated legacy and unfulfilled promises. The gripe goes like this: Once it seemed the marketplace would continue growing into a more expansive space and the medium of film itself would continue evolving and maturing, forever and ever. Instead, these movements stalled and fragmented as New Hollywood – adapting to multiplex economics, seduced by the success of brand-birthing event films that favored cutting-edge sensationalism, out-of-this-world escapism, and nostalgia for the genre fantasies of their youth -- morphed into Franchise Hollywood.
The Holdovers could be seen as contributing to this mourning and agreeing with its complaints. But for all its admiration for seventies cinema, The Holdovers pushes back against the earnestly felt yet increasingly fashionable and hollow "Forget it Jake, it's Chinatown" cynicism of the era, questioning if not grieving its influence and legacy. Viewing the film as meta-commentary on this theme, you could see its (qualified) redemption arcs as acts of wishful wondering about what kind of cultural impact that a more sanguine/less doomy seventies cinema might have had on the culture. In this way, The Holdovers is similar to Paul Thomas Anderson's Licorice Pizza (which also aped the style of seventies cinema to talk back to seventies culture) and Quentin Tarantino's Once Upon A Time In Hollywood, a revisionist fantasy that allowed its characters to war against the dark spirits of their age and win.
Part of the meta-fun of The Holdovers for a certain kind of movie fan is recognizing the movies that inform its style and might be commenting on. To be clear, The Holdovers doesn’t call out its reference points, and any claim to see at all might be an eye-of-the-beholder thing or a projection that’s dead-wrong about Payne’s intentions. This is all to say… that this essay is about to get a little Doc Jensen crazy.
For example, where many see an affectionate ode to Hal Ashby in The Holdovers, I see Payne wrangling with the legacy of Stanley Kubrick and the bleakness that permeates every movie he made after 2001: A Space Odyssey. I had A Clockwork Orange on the brain from the moment we meet Sessna’s Angus Tully, who’s face, anger, and theatrically impish spirit kept reminding me of Malcolm McDowell’s Alex DeLarge (minus the accent and raping, of course). Alex’s world is a dystopian ruin of classical culture; his whole ironic, nihilistic shtick acts out against the Romantic notion that high art can refine us and utopian engineering can save us. Similarly, Angus, coming of age in an era of post-sixties heartbreak and malaise, is just as savvy and cynical about his world, and I kept wondering what he might make of A Clockwork Orange, which looms one year in his future, and if he might see himself in Alex, and how he might relate to him.
And then there’s The Shining of it all. Paul Giamatti playing de facto caretaker (and wannabe writer of monographs) of a holiday-emptied boarding school with ancient history and run by dubious management kept reminding me of the Overlook Hotel, a symbol of American rot, an incubator for cultivating the worst in people, not the best. Professor Hunham – a hemorrhoidal hard-ass warped by pain, failure, and shame – takes out his impotency on his students, using and abusing the privilege of impacting the lives of blue blood boys the way Jack Torrance chased after his family with an axe, as an opportunity to “correct” them with brutal, demeaning snark, or just cut them down for good out of blame-shifting bitterness.
This not to say that The Holdovers is Kubrickian at all. It’s NOT. It shares some agreement with perspectives we see in Kubrick films, but it’s lighter tone and gracious, generous regard for its characters – particularly in its belief that people have as much good in them than bad and can change, for the better – argues against Kubrick’s chilling hopelessness. Hunham's winter adventure ends with a spiritual thaw; he drops his axe and escapes his Overlook Hotel and hits the road to grow in grace and find his place. The Holdovers doesn’t have much faith in institutions, but it does believe people can change, and help each other to change, and make sacrifices to help their flourishing. Which means this movie about people needing Christmas movie and New Year’s renewal is just like Kubrick’s last movie, Eyes Wide Shut… but that’s a nutty theory for another time.
Comments